Are Groupon and Living Social Engaged in Illegal Fee-Splitting?

As most of you are, I’m subscribed to Groupon, LivingSocial and a few other flash sales or daily deal sites. One recent offer from Groupon got me thinking.

Many states have laws for professions that don’t allow any third parties to be involved in transactions with customers, clients or patients.  Depending on the state, the law may cover doctors, dentists, lawyers, real estate agents, or other professionals.

That means no kickbacks, or fee sharing.

Hey, I am no lawyer and of course can’t provide a legal opinion, but my layperson’s opinion is that Groupon may be in violation of
New York Public Health – § 4501 – Medical Referral Service Businesses Prohibited

as is any medical practitioner advertising on Groupon since Groupon takes the money from the customer and keeps some of it.
http://law.onecle.com/new-york/public-health/PBH02811_2811.html

http://www.articlesbase.com/criminal-articles/how-illegal-fee-splitting-may-cost-you-your-new-york-medical-license-771901.html

Spot checks of Groupon, LivingSocial and some other group buying sites seems to indicate that this practice is prevalent with dentists, chiropractors and dermatologists in particular.

Wonder if I’m completely off-base here or if indeed there is a problem that’s slipped under the radar.

Originally, I became aware of the laws because my wife is a psychologist, and I was wondering if she could offer a Groupon-type deal.  Plus, I’m an investor in DiscountCoupons.com and had an interest in this type of arrangement from the offer-network as well.

Bruce Clay on Social Media and SEO

Interview between Didit CEO Kevin Lee and Bruce Clay Inc. CEO Bruce Clay, recorded at Ad:Tech New York, November, 2010. In this segment, Kevin and Bruce discuss social media and SEO.

Bruce Clay on Personalization and SEO

Interview between Didit CEO Kevin Lee and Bruce Clay Inc. CEO Bruce Clay, recorded at Ad:Tech New York, November, 2010. In this segment, Kevin and Bruce discuss personalization and SEO.

Bruce Clay on Changes to the Local SERP

Interview between Didit CEO Kevin Lee and Bruce Clay Inc. CEO Bruce Clay, recorded at Ad:Tech New York, November, 2010. In this segment, Kevin and Bruce discuss Changes to the Local SERP (Search Engine Results Page).

Bruce Clay on Search Engine Algorithm Differentiation

Interview between Didit CEO Kevin Lee and Bruce Clay Inc. CEO Bruce Clay, recorded at Ad:Tech New York, November, 2010. In this segment, Kevin and Bruce discuss search engine algorithm differentiation.

Kaijsa Kurstin (Bidding For Good) on Cause Marketing

Interview between Didit CEO/We-Care Founder Kevin Lee and Kaijsa Kurstin, Media Relations Manager, BiddingForGood. In this segment, Kevin and Kaijsa discuss cause marketing. Recorded October, 2010.

Kaijsa Kurstin (Bidding For Good) on Online vs. Live Auctions for Fundraising

Interview between Didit CEO/We-Care Founder Kevin Lee and Kaijsa Kurstin, Media Relations Manager, BiddingForGood. In this segment, Kevin and Kaijsa discuss online vs. “live” (offline) auctions. Recorded October, 2010.

Kaijsa Kurstin on Cause Marketing For Small Businesses

Interview between Didit CEO/We-Care Founder Kevin Lee and Kaijsa Kurstin, Media Relations Manager, BiddingForGood. In this segment, Kevin and Kaijsa discuss cause marketing for small businesses.
Recorded October, 2010.

Kaijsa Kurstin on Auctions’ Ability to Stimulate Product Trials

Interview between Didit CEO/We-Care Founder Kevin Lee and Kaijsa Kurstin, Media Relations Manager, BiddingForGood. In this segment, Kevin and Kaijsa discuss online auctions’ ability to stimulate product trials. Recorded October, 2010.

Kaijsa Kurstin on the Most Interesting Auctioned Item

Interview between Didit CEO/We-Care Founder Kevin Lee and Kaijsa Kurstin, Media Relations Manager, BiddingForGood. In this segment, Kevin and Kaijsa discuss the most interesting item auctioned by BiddingForGood. Recorded October, 2010.

Kaijsa Kurstin on Firms Using Donations For PR

Interview between Didit CEO/We-Care Founder Kevin Lee and Kaijsa Kurstin, Media Relations Manager, BiddingForGood. In this segment, Kevin and Kaijsa discuss firms using donations for positive public relations. Recorded October, 2010.

Kaijsa Kurstin on The Relationship Between Bidder Number and Bidder Price

Kaijsa Kurstin on Promoting Online Auctions

Kaijsa Kurstin on Social Media and Online Auctions

Interview between Didit CEO/We-Care Founder Kevin Lee and Kaijsa Kurstin, Media Relations Manager, BiddingForGood. In this segment, Kevin and Kaijsa discuss social media and online auctions. Recorded October, 2010.

Kevin Lee and Dave Pasternack Debate Issues of the Day